Sánchez-Betances, Sifre & Muñoz-Noya, P.S.C.Sánchez-Betances, Sifre & Muñoz-Noya, P.S.C.Sánchez-Betances, Sifre & Muñoz-Noya, P.S.C.Sánchez-Betances, Sifre & Muñoz-Noya, P.S.C.
  • About
  • Attorneys
    • Betsy Asencio-Quiles
    • Milagros T. Cuadrado-Camacho
    • Luis M. Ferrer-Medina
    • Nerylú Figueroa-Estasie
    • Julio I. Lugo-Muñoz
    • Daniel Molina-Lopez
    • Ángel Muñoz-Noya
    • Claribel Ortiz-Rodríguez
    • Adrián Sánchez-Pagán
    • Luis Sánchez-Betances
    • Sergio Sánchez-Pagán
    • Vicente A. Sequeda-Torres
    • Nolan A. Vargas Sanabria
    • Marta E. Vilá-Báez
  • Practice Areas
    • Civil and Commercial Litigation
    • Labor and Employment Law
    • Health Law
    • Insurance Law
    • Corporate and Tax Law
    • Notary
  • Clients
  • Publications
    • References
  • Contact Us

U.S. District Court Dismisses Claims for Discrimination and Retaliation

    Home News U.S. District Court Dismisses Claims for Discrimination and Retaliation

    U.S. District Court Dismisses Claims for Discrimination and Retaliation

    By Julio I Lugo Muñoz | News | Comments are Closed | 13 February, 2017 | 0

    On January 11, 2017, The United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico issued an Opinion an Order Dismissing with Prejudice a claim for discrimination and retaliation under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act; including supplemental claims under Puerto Rico law, filed against Plaintiff’s former employer, a client of our Firm.

     

    Plaintiff alleged that from June 2011 until her resignation in November 2013 she was subjected to a hostile work environment by the Company top officers. Also, she alleged that younger and male employees who performed similar duties earned higher salaries and bonuses than she did.  As part of her claims she also alleged that after she filed a charge before the EEOC the harassment increased and became so unbearable that she was forced to resign.

     

    The Court dismissed the claim after we filed a Motion for Summary Judgment. The Motion was based on Plaintiff’s lack of admissible evidence to substantiate her allegations and comply with the prima facie standards. To the contrary, the direct and admissible evidence demonstrated that Plaintiff was not treated discriminatorily in terms of salaries, bonuses and/or any other type of compensation and that she was, instead, the second best pay employee of the enterprise, only second to defendant’s General Manager. Plaintiff also lacked sufficient evidence in support of her remaining discrimination and retaliation claims for hostile work environment and constructive discharge.

     

    The Court concluded based on the evidence and the applicable law that Plaintiff was not treated in a discriminatory fashion.

     

    Regarding a procedural matter, common in this type of situations, the Court emphasized that Plaintiff’s opposition to summary judgement was basically relying on a post discovery affidavit that merely repeated the allegations stated in the Complaint; and that the same were vague, conclusory and mere allegations that do not, as required to adequately survive a Summary Judgement, offered details and specific facts, as well as context and specificity to what was alleged.

     

    The Court concluded, in sum, that Plaintiff’s allegations were only supported by hearsay evidence and conclusory statements in her affidavit and that, thus, she cannot establish a prima facie case of discrimination or retaliation under the federal and local statutes invoked. It was also concluded that Plaintiff’s Law 80 claim of unjust dismissal fails since she was not terminated.

     

    This article is not and should not be taken as legal advice or counseling. It is for informative purposes only. For advice, you should consult an attorney of your choice. 

     

     

    No tags.

    Related Post

    • Transparencia y confianza

      By Luis Sánchez-Betances, Esq. | Comments are Closed

      Read more

    • La solución contra la criminalidad

      By Luis Sánchez-Betances, Esq. | Comments are Closed

      Publicada en El Nuevo Día: lunes, 21 de octubre de 2019Read more

    • Back to work for Puerto Rico

      By María Moreno | Comments are Closed

      Sánchez-Betances, Sifre & Muñoz-Noya stands in solidarity with the people of Puerto Rico in this tragic chapter of our history. Our hope is that all our friends and clients are safe and well. Together we willRead more

    • Act to Regulate the Profession of Physician Assistant of Puerto Rico

      By José M. Álvarez-Allende | Comments are Closed

      On August 5, 2017, Act No. 71, “Act to Regulate the Profession of Physician Assistant of Puerto Rico”, was approved. The Act establishes the academic, professional ethic and continuing education process requirements for Physicians AssistantsRead more

    • Equal Payment Salary Act

      By José M. Álvarez-Allende | Comments are Closed

      On March 8, 2017, Act. # 17 of 2017, better known as the Puerto Rico Equal Pay Act, was approved. The Act establishes the public policy as to equal pay for equal work, seeking toRead more

    Recent Publications

    • Transparencia y confianza
    • La solución contra la criminalidad
    • The Act of God Defense in a Maritime Claim
    • Back to work for Puerto Rico
    • Act to Regulate the Profession of Physician Assistant of Puerto Rico

    Categories

    • column
    • News
    • Uncategorized

    info@sbsmnlaw.com
    tel (787) 756 7880
    fax (787) 753 6580 

    33 Bolivia Street, 5th Floor
    San Juan, PR 00917
    PO Box 364428
    San Juan, PR 00936-4428
    • About
    • Attorneys
    • Practice Areas
    • Clients
    • Publications
    • Contact Us
    • Site Map
    Terms of Use | © document.getElementById('copyright').appendChild(document.createTextNode(new Date().getFullYear())) Sánchez-Betances, Sifre & Muñoz-Noya | Concept by Maria Cristina Moreno-Villarreal & Developed by Mio Puerto Rico
    • About
    • Attorneys
      • Betsy Asencio-Quiles
      • Milagros T. Cuadrado-Camacho
      • Luis M. Ferrer-Medina
      • Nerylú Figueroa-Estasie
      • Julio I. Lugo-Muñoz
      • Daniel Molina-Lopez
      • Ángel Muñoz-Noya
      • Claribel Ortiz-Rodríguez
      • Adrián Sánchez-Pagán
      • Luis Sánchez-Betances
      • Sergio Sánchez-Pagán
      • Vicente A. Sequeda-Torres
      • Nolan A. Vargas Sanabria
      • Marta E. Vilá-Báez
    • Practice Areas
      • Civil and Commercial Litigation
      • Labor and Employment Law
      • Health Law
      • Insurance Law
      • Corporate and Tax Law
      • Notary
    • Clients
    • Publications
      • References
    • Contact Us
    Sánchez-Betances, Sifre & Muñoz-Noya, P.S.C.